Wednesday, September 30, 2015

Blackstone: Aurora

For September's convocation of the Blackstone Fantasy & Science Fiction book group, we discussed Kim Stanley Robinson's newly-released novel "Aurora".

In "Aurora", Robinson ventures out of the solar system for the first time, following a group of colonists on a generational starship to Tau Ceti (a popular SF destination). The generational starship is a staple of interstellar SF that eschews FTL, since it's one of only a few ways one can get characters to other stars without violating the laws of physics.

The twist here is that Robinson is directly challenging the easy optimism that characterizes the overwhelming majority of space exploration science fiction--the Tau Ceti mission runs into a slew of deep problems, from biology, from sociology, and from the laws of physics. In so doing, he's both making this a bit harder than the usual "hard SF" and also making a point about Earth and the folly of assuming we could easily leave it.

Our general consensus was that we really liked the novel, but felt (as many reviewers have) that KSR stacked the deck a little too hard to make his points. Probable spoilers below!

Thursday, February 26, 2015

Blackstone FSF: The Ocean at the End of the Lane

Good, quick meeting on Neil Gaiman's "The Ocean at the End of the Lane" with the Blackstone Library's Fantasy & Science Fiction club on Monday. Some new (to me faces) at group, including occasional group-attender and author Shane Holbach, who actually is sharing a table of contents with Gaiman (and a slew of other fantastic authors) in a YA Speculative Fiction Anthology from Twelfth Planet.

For a surprising number of folks at the table, this was their first time with Gaiman, which is kind of interesting. "Ocean" is really good, lyrical, but it's an unusual starting place: not the tour de force of "American Gods" (2001), not a "Now A Feature Film!" like "Coraline" (2002) or "Stardust" (1999); at least in the circles I run in, the "Sandman" comics (1989-1996) are almost universally the entry-point.

I really, really like Gaiman's work at shorter lengths--"Smoke & Mirrors" (1998) and "Fragile Things" (2006) are highly recommended, and his latest collection, "Trigger Warning", just hit shelves. Additionally, his children's/YA-ish lit game is very strong, whether that's dark fairy-tales like "Coraline" (illustrated by Dave McKean) or playful illustrated works like "Fortunately, The Milk" (2013, ill. Skottie Young). "The Ocean at the End of the Lane", while not necessarily for younger readers, is told primarily from a child's perspective, has a sort of childish straight-forward prose style, and is quite short--close to the novella range, really--thus combining some of Gaiman's strengths. Indeed, despite the child's perspective, I think this is one of the most mature and measured I've seen Gaiman--there is a big dose of autobiographical material here, and the fantastic, alternating terrifying/comforting world of the child's story resonates very nicely with the larger framing narrative, the grown man remembering with some amount of melancholy.

The group had lots of praise for the style of the book, calling it a "prose poem" and noting how it's both "utter simplicity, but tremendously atmospheric".

Friday, January 30, 2015

Blackstone FSF: The Thief

On Monday the Blackstone Library Fantasy & Science Fiction book club discussed Megan Whalen Turner's "The Thief" (1996), a Newberry Honor book. A fun read, good discussion! Serious, definite spoilers after the jump:

Thursday, December 25, 2014

Blackstone F & SF: Ancillary Justice


Ann Leckie's “Ancillary Justice”, whatever else it is, is certainly turning into a touchstone for the SF community—I can't think of a book in recent years that so many people are reading and discussing, regardless of their usual tastes in the genre. Last night the Blackstone Fantasy & Science Fiction Book Club took a crack at it. Spoilers and nitpicks below!

Tuesday, November 25, 2014

Blackstone F&SF: Dragon Keeper

Last night I ventured south to attend the Blackstone Library Fantasy & Science Fiction Book Club's discussion of "Dragon Keeper" (2009) by Robin Hobb. Blackstone is a beautiful library--marble, dark timber, brass--that in some difficult-to-describe way also looks like it might be haunted. Delightful.

A good book-club!  A lot of long-time fans and readers, with lots of discussion, argument, and comparison to other works. Much to my liking. Possible spoilers below...